| 1998 Boys All-County Team | Avg | 1998 Girls All-County Team | Avg | |
| Matt Himmelreich (GM) | 214 | Kristin Aulenbach (Rdg) | 210 | |
| Rick Maryniak (GM) | 211 | Nicole Putt (CW) | 208 | |
| Ben Schwenk (Wils) | 211 | Steph Rishell (GM) | 207 | |
| Tyler Giles (Rdg) | 211 | Kristie Monshower (Ex) | 205 | |
| Sean Wyandt (Wils) | 211 | Haley Gehringer (Rdg) | 201 | |
| 1997 Boys All-County Team | Avg | 1997 Girls All-County Team | Avg | |
| Heath Brightbill (GM) | 225 | Kristin Aulenbach (Rdg) | 200 | |
| Ben Schwenk (Wils) | 218 | Kristie Monshower (Ex) | 198 | |
| Keith Brightbill (GM) | 217 | Haley Gehringer (Rdg) | 197 | |
| Brian Kochel (SV) | 215 | Stephanie Yovish (Hamb) | 193 | |
| Matt Himmelreich (GM) | 209 | Steph Rishell (GM) | 193 | |
| 1996 Boys All-County Team | Avg | 1996 Girls All-County Team | Avg | |
| Chad Horrigan (GM) | 219 | Haley Gehringer (Rdg) | 202 | |
| John Wisniewski (CC) | 219 | Jessica Ricker (GM) | 195 | |
| Heath Brightbill (GM) | 218 | Kristin Aulenbach (Rdg) | 193 | |
| Lee Wentzel (Wils) | 216 | Christy Hawley (GM) | 193 | |
| Jason Tolley (TV) | 209 | Becky Sparr (DB) | 191 | |